How to swap Substack recommendations
A recommendation swap is two writers recommending each other's newsletter on Substack. When someone subscribes to you, Substack shows them your recommendations, and one tap subscribes them to those too.
Substack says more than half of new subscribers come from its own network (Substack, About). Recommendations are one of the biggest parts of that network, and the part you control.
Why the swap matters more than the recommendation
- Ian Powers counted where his recommendation sign-ups came from: the 4 publications he recommends back sent 77 of his 87 (Write Sports).
- Carrie Loranger has 278 publications recommending her, and they sent 1,637 subscribers. Her advice: read their latest post first, and favor writers at your size (9-To-Thrive).
The 5 steps
- 1
Find partners near your size
Pick newsletters in your topics with half your subscriber count up to 10 times it. The free partner finder lists 20 in that band for you, closest to twice your size first.
Find your recommendation partners - 2
Check that they still post
Open their archive. Substack puts a recommended publication in its digest emails only if it posted in the last 30 days, so a quiet newsletter gets less from your recommendation and gives your readers less.
- 3
Recommend them first
In your Substack dashboard, open Recommendations, search for the publication, and add one sentence on why your readers will like it. Substack does not always email the writer about it, so do not count on them seeing it.
- 4
Send one short message
Name one recent post of theirs and what you liked in it, say you already recommend them, and ask if a recommendation back fits their readers. Keep it to four sentences.
- 5
Check what each swap sends
The Recommendations page shows the subscribers each recommendation sent you in the last 30 days and since it started. After 60 days, keep the partners who send readers and free the slot from the ones who do not.
Dashboard steps, digest and email rules: Substack support, “How can I recommend other publications on Substack?”
What did not work for us
At Build to Launch, we recommended back four writers who were already sending us readers, and sent no message. In the 90 days before, they sent 34 subscribers. In the 90 days after, 13. Four cases is too few to prove anything, but a silent recommend-back did not bring more. Now each one goes with a short note.
Get the next playbook
Build to Launch is Jenny Ouyang's newsletter for people who use AI and want to go further with it. She tests growth moves like this one on her own newsletter and shares the numbers.
Subscribe to Build to Launch, free